Foam and mineral wool: which is better for insulation, differences

Your home’s comfort and energy efficiency can be greatly impacted by the insulation you choose. Foam and mineral wool are two common insulation options, each with pros and cons of their own.

Spray foam and rigid foam boards are two types of foam insulation that have good heat resistance. It produces a tight seal, which can result in lower heating and cooling expenses by lowering air infiltration and heat loss. Because of its adaptability, foam insulation can be used in crawl spaces, attics, and walls in homes.

However, mineral wool insulation, which is derived from slag or rock fibers, is also a good way to block heat. Due to its reputation for soundproofing and fire resistance, it is the material of choice in settings where noise abatement and fire safety are top concerns. Because mineral wool resists moisture and doesn’t encourage the growth of mold, it is appropriate for humid spaces like basements.

Think about the qualities of each material and your particular needs when choosing between mineral wool and foam. Mineral wool has good fire resistance and sound absorption qualities, while foam insulation excels at producing airtight seals and optimizing thermal performance. Budget, the effect on the environment, and local building codes are a few more variables that could influence the decision.

Comparison on the main characteristics

If you’re unsure about which material is better—mineral wool or polystyrene foam—the most sensible option will be compared, and each material will be examined. Foamine is foam made of extruded polystyrene. Additionally, there are various types of mineral wool or insulation.

Their differences are found in their appearance, structure, and operational parameters. However, insulators made of various materials are composed. Additionally, their production technology is distinct.

I’d like to go over a few important points because every one of them will have an impact on your decision.

Material and appearance

The foam is actually high-tech polystyrene foam. He’s made of foam. High pressure and temperature were applied to it. The end product was an extremely lightweight, tightly-knit material with outstanding thermal insulation properties. appears to be frozen mounting foam from the outside. Furthermore, because mineral wool is composed of rock silicates, it contains fibers. The corresponding properties of a material are obtained through the melting of raw materials.

Varieties

Minvat is separated into multiple groups. It’s stone cotton wool, glass wool, and slag wool. The latter is more typical. You can confirm this using basalt cotton wool as an example. Its technical features are the best. Additionally, the foam is differentiated based on the application’s scope. The walls, ceiling, and other sections are all supported by the same frothy foundation.

Price, weight and packaging

The cost of good basalt wool is comparable to that of foam. As a result, insulation will have the same cost. The manufacturer determines the price. weighs stone cotton wool, which adds a little difficulty to the installation process. putting both isolators inside films with a heat seat.

Thermal insulation parameters

What’s warmer piques the curiosity of many. Low thermal conductivity materials are the best choice for insulation. The foam is superior here. However, the distinction is negligible. For instance, a foam that is 50 mm thick and 60 mm thick will function just as well as mineral wool. Additionally, thermal conductivity parameters will drastically decline if you fail to provide protection and adhere to installation guidelines. Therefore, without taking into account the problem on a particular example, it cannot be said that it is warmer.

Vapor permeability

Which is better in this case, mineral wool or foam? unclear parameter. With a vapor permeability coefficient that is almost zero, the foamyplex is warmer. This describes a nearly total tightness. Minvata has the benefit of breathing, which is important when thinking about condensate protection. Vata allows air to pass through it. However, there will be a waterproofing layer that lowers this very vapor permeability when laying a prerequisite.

Combustibility and resistance to fire

Minvat wins here, unconditionally. It is non-combustible and requires a temperature of more than a thousand degrees Celsius to melt. It is easy to ignite the foam. Special additives helped to partially eliminate this drawback.

Which material is where it is better to use

You must base your decision between mineral wool and foam on concrete instances. Sometimes the best course of action is to use foam insulation for insulation. Objectively speaking, the penumplex has become outdated, much like mineral wool, but the least expensive foam prevailed.

After comparing materials like foam and stone cotton or basalt wool, you should consider an insulator’s capacity to function well under particular circumstances.

Professionals offer their advice on which is better for thermal insulation projects: minvat or extruded foam. They offer the following advice:

• Inner walls . From the inside the walls can be insulated with both a foam and mineral wool. But if this is a wooden building, a frame house is insulated, then it is better to use mineral wool. This is due to the best vaporoprovenity indicators;
• Foundation, blind area, base and basements . The foam manifests itself more effectively here. This can be explained by the best strength indicators, as well as the ability to withstand heavy loads;
• Roof . Mineral cotton wool is suitable here, as well as extruded polystyrene foam. The choice should be made based on the building material at home. Basically, for ceilings, attic and attics use high -quality stone cotton wool;
• High humidity premises . These are structures such as saunas, baths or car wash. Under such humidity conditions, it is strictly not recommended to take polystyrene foam. That is, Minvat here becomes a non -alternative and most correct choice.

As you can see, there is no definitive response to the query of which of these heaters is superior. It is important to consider a variety of elements and to build upon particular circumstances. There is no other way to choose wisely than this.

Which is more convenient and easier to install

When deciding between mineral wool and polystyrene foam, it’s important to think about how convenient and simple it will be to install the insulators.

I suggest that you consider these instances when organizing the application of thermal insulation materials, such as polystyrene foam or mineral west. This will help you determine whether foam or mineral wool is better for your particular situation:

• The foam is less, which simplifies installation work. But the use of extruded polystyrene foam provides for a more reliable and high -quality fastening to the surface. Because of this, ready-made products connecting by the principle of spike-paz appeared on sale. If there is no such connection, it is better to take 2 layers of a thinner foam, and lay with an overlap of the seam. This increases costs. But the foam is convenient and easy to process. It is easy to cut it;
• Minvat is somewhat heavier. But this does not affect the comfort of work. Mineral wool effectively closes all irregularities, and compensates for not leveled walls. With a foam truck this will not work. But with Minvata, you need to work strictly in accordance with the safety rules using protective equipment (mask, glasses and gloves).

The best thing about both materials is that even a novice can use them. It was therefore impossible to determine the winner’s convenience or ease of installation.

There are a few things to consider when choosing between mineral wool and foam for the front of your house insulation. Expanded polystyrene (EPS) and polyurethane are examples of foam insulation that is well-known for its high heat resistance and capacity to form a tight seal against air infiltration. This can lessen heat loss through walls, which can greatly increase energy efficiency.

Conversely, mineral wool—which includes glass and rock wool—offers superior soundproofing and fire resistance. Because it is composed of recyclable or natural materials, it is a more environmentally friendly option for insulation. Additionally breathable, mineral wool permits moisture to permeate walls without impairing its insulating qualities.

The way they are installed and handled is one important distinction. Whereas mineral wool is more adaptable to various facade designs due to its ease of fitting around irregular shapes and corners, foam insulation usually requires careful application to ensure a proper seal.

Cost may also play a decisive role. Because foam insulation has greater thermal performance and requires more installation work, it is typically more expensive up front. Despite being a little less costly, mineral wool provides good value due to its acoustic and fire resistance qualities.

In conclusion, the decision between mineral wool and foam insulation comes down to your personal priorities. If airtightness and energy efficiency are top concerns, foam insulation might be a better fit. Mineral wool is probably a better option for exterior insulation if you value environmental factors, soundproofing, and fire safety.

Mineral wool and foam are two popular materials for home insulation, and each has advantages and disadvantages of its own. Similar to spray foam, foam insulation provides good air leak sealing and thermal resistance. It is simple to install in difficult-to-reach places and lightweight. Conversely, mineral wool, which is composed of slag or rock fibers, has good soundproofing and fire resistance qualities. It doesn’t deteriorate with time and is safe for the environment. The best type for your home’s insulation requirements will depend on a number of factors, including your budget, insulation requirements, and environmental concerns. It is important to carefully consider each of these factors when making your decision.

Video on the topic

Mineral wool or extruded polystyrene foam / the better to insulate the house / Rockwool / Penopolex Comfort

Why polyurethane foam is better than mineral wool as a heater

Foam or mineral wool – which is better?

Which insulation to choose for home? Minvata, Ecowata, PIR, Foam? Pros and cons of all heaters

Home insulation | Foam, foam or mineral wool? What a heater?

Insulation. Foam, mineral wool. Warmth or threat of life?

Stone wool that is important to know about density different density for the roof, floor and walls